Fired Over a Six-Word Facebook Post: Colby Martin on But What About . . .

Description:

In 2011, an evangelical pastor posted six words on Facebook the night Don’t Ask, Don’t Tell ended. By Monday, he was fired. Five years later, his book UnClobber helped Jen realign her mind and heart on LGBTQ inclusion. Colby shares the board meeting that ended his evangelical career and why he fell for “boring” Episcopal liturgy. Then they dig into his new book, But What About . . ., and the questions he hears everywhere: What about Adam and Eve? Biblical marriage? Doesn’t God make mistakes with gender? If your heart and head are pulling in two directions, this is for you.

Thought-provoking Quotes:

  • “I lost the three primary identity markers that I had inadvertently built my life upon.” – Colby Martin
  • “I think better beliefs lead to better churches.” – Colby Martin
  • “It’s not ‘be perfect as your Father in heaven is perfect,’ but ‘be whole.'” – Colby Martin
  • “It’s not their burden to manage other people’s homophobia.” – Jen Hatmaker
  • “Thank God all those incredible thinkers and leaders just held a door open for me.” – Jen Hatmaker

Resources Mentioned in This Episode:

JHBC: Wm. Paul Young on Return to the Shack, Death Row Friendships, and a God Who Is Good

Description:

Twenty years ago, Wm. Paul Young wrote a story as a Christmas gift for his six kids, printed 15 copies at Office Depot, and went back to work at one of his three jobs. That story became The Shack. Now Paul returns with Return to the Shack, our Jen Hatmaker Book Club pick for October, set ten years after the original and shaped by a decade of real friendship with the men of Unit 2 on death row in Nashville. Jen and Paul talk about the long road of healing that came before The Shack, the uncanny ways the book keeps finding the people who need it, why the backlash never shook him, and what his friends on death row have taught him about freedom. Stay until the very end for Paul’s gentle, unforgettable answer to anyone who grew up terrified of hell.

Thought-provoking Quotes:

  • “You do the next right thing, you participate with love, and you trust the ripples.” (Wm. Paul Young)
  • “When you learn to live without expectations, everything becomes a gift.” (Wm. Paul Young)
  • “Fury and grief together are the basis for compassion.” (Wm. Paul Young)
  • “It’s not about purpose. It’s about moment by moment response to the person, the event that is actually in front of you.” (Wm. Paul Young)
  • “A lot of people live way past their theology because they’re better human beings than their theology would allow them to be.” (Wm. Paul Young)

Resources Mentioned in This Episode:

Jen and Friends: Jamie Golden on the Midterms, Botox, and What to Watch Next

Description:

Welcome to the very first episode of Jen and Friends, a new monthly segment where Jen pulls up a chair with one of her actual friends. No book tour, no agenda, no interview; just the conversation you’d overhear if you were eavesdropping. First up is the hilarious Jamie Golden, cohost of The Popcast with Knox and Jamie, Faith Adjacent, and Shelf Respect, flying solo on the show for the first time. Recorded the day after the midterms, Jen and Jamie open with a morning-after debrief from Texas and Alabama, then wander happily through purpose-driven alliteration (and the book title nobody stopped Jen from using), the Rachel haircut that swept Oklahoma Baptist University, and a famous-Christian wedding Jamie attended on a tolerance invitation. Then skincare savant Jamie explains snail mucin, why South Korea bet big on beauty and entertainment, the three products you actually need, and why Jen’s Botox keeps going sideways. Plus: what to watch next, from The Traitors to War to Slow Horses. Consider this your breather.

Thought-provoking Quotes:

“What is more enough than a good friend and an hour to laugh?” – Jen Hatmaker

“Should we talk about everything and nothing all at the same time?” – Jamie Golden

“Could be so much worse. It’s the new American slogan.” – Jen Hatmaker

“Skincare is like a seasoning in a dish.” – Jamie Golden

“All you need is a cleanser, a sunscreen, and a moisturizer. That’s it.” – Jamie Golden

Resources Mentioned in This Episode:

The Popcast with Knox and Jamie – https://knoxandjamie.com

Faith Adjacent – https://podcasts.apple.com/podcast/id1347735219

Shelf Respect – https://readwithshelfrespect.com

Flawless by Elise Hu – https://www.penguinrandomhouse.com/books/667034/flawless-by-elise-hu/

The Traitors on Peacock – https://www.peacocktv.com/stream-tv/the-traitors

The Diplomat on Netflix – https://www.netflix.com/title/81288983

East of Eden on Netflix – https://www.netflix.com/tudum/articles/east-of-eden-series

The Great British Baking Show on Netflix – https://www.netflix.com/title/80063224

The Morning After Midterms: You Still Have Enough (Jen Hatmaker Solo Episode)

Description:

If you’re hearing this the morning it drops, the midterms wrapped yesterday. I recorded this last week, on purpose, so I don’t know how it went. I don’t know what you woke up feeling, and honestly, I don’t know what I’m feeling yet either. Relieved, defeated, somewhere in between: either way, we still have to get up and make breakfast.

We’re opening our November series on Enough, and today it’s just me and you with the most basic version of it: you have enough in you to show up today, no matter what happened yesterday. I’m asking three questions. What do you still have that you had yesterday? What can you set down, or hand to someone else, for 24 hours? And what is the next small thing that’s yours to do?

Setting something down is not quitting. Being a good neighbor is not a small thing. And as we head into the holiday season, maybe facing some hard firsts, you also get to say enough is enough. I want all of us to have enough left for the long game.

Thought-provoking Quotes:

  • Enough really isn’t a feeling. For me, sometimes I see it more as a count.
  • Setting something down is not quitting. Resting is not quitting. Pausing is not quitting.
  • Hope can be so exhausting when you’re just trying to hold it up in the air with all your might.
  • We can’t fix everything, but we do have to have dinner.
  • Being a good neighbor to me is the highest apex of my faith.
  • I believe that we belong to each other, and that we have far more in common than what separates us.

Resources Mentioned in This Episode:

Encore: Top Chef’s Kristen Kish on Last Chances, Making Big Changes and Living a Life That’s Accidentally On Purpose

She’s become a leading voice in the culinary world and today stars as the lead host of the same cooking competition show that launched her career. Kristen Kish was eliminated from Bravo’s season 10 of Top Chef, only to make a triumphant return through a Last Chance Kitchen opportunity that cleared the way for her to beat out the remaining competition and win the season. 

Since that 2013 victory, Kristen has been everywhere – launching a new restaurant, Arlo Grey, in Jen’s hometown of Austin (and another restaurant opening soon in New York), hosting some of our favorite food shows including Kitchens at the End of the World, Iron Chef, and now Top Chef (the student has become the teacher). She’s also flexing a new muscle as an author. In her new book, Accidentally on Purpose, Kristen shares her story of being born in South Korea and adopted into a loving white, midwestern American family and what it was like for her to navigate her identity in all of its racial, sexual and professional contexts. Ultimately, what defines Kristen’s story is how she learned to find her voice and use it and, while accidents may be unexpected, they don’t have to be at odds with our purpose. 

Our conversation today covers: 

  • Pivoting, embracing change, and building a life that is truthful and authentic
  • How the road to success was so much more winding and complicated than it may have appeared from the outside
  • Knowing internally that it’s time to make a change or take a new step forward
  • How it’s the behind-the-scenes, off camera moments that nobody sees where the decisions and discoveries are made, where the unexpected meets the intentional, and where things get really interesting.
  • Battling imposter syndrome and burnout and quieting the voice of doubt
  • How life’s best opportunities often come from embracing the unexpected

Don’t Make It Worse: Surviving the Midterms and Thanksgiving Dinner with Pantsuit Politics

Description:

With the midterms days away, Sarah Stewart Holland and Beth Silvers of Pantsuit Politics break down what is really on the ballot, how to make sure your vote counts, and how to survive the Thanksgiving table when your family lands all over the map. This isn’t an episode about how to vote. It’s about how to be a person right now.

Thought-provoking Quotes:

“It doesn’t cost me anything to listen to people.” – Beth Silvers

“Your vote counts more in the midterm elections because fewer people vote.” – Beth Silvers

“If you ask people to silence that, you lose the opportunity to connect.” – Sarah Stewart Holland

Resources Mentioned in This Episode:

Sarah and Beth’s books – https://bookshop.org/lists/pantsuit-politics-book-club

Up First from NPR – https://www.npr.org/podcasts/510318/up-first

The Daily – https://www.nytimes.com/column/the-daily

The Ezra Klein Show – https://www.nytimes.com/column/ezra-klein-podcast

For the Love with Priya Parker – https://jenhatmaker.com/podcast

Meander Bookshop – https://bookshop.org/shop/meanderbookshop

Also mentioned: Start Here (ABC News), The New York Times, Axios, News Items, and Mary Higgins Clark’s Where Are the Children?

Kim Hill and Paulette Wooten: We Fell in Love and Lost Our Whole World

Kim Hill had the kind of run most artists only dream of: number one songs on Christian radio, arena stages, and the biggest women’s conferences in the country. Paulette Wooten was a songwriter, musician, and ordained music minister helping build the modern worship movement from the inside. Then they met at a worship school, played a 45-minute set together as near strangers, and a year and a half of friendship on the road quietly turned into love. In a world where that was not allowed, they chose each other anyway.

As part of our Courage to Change: Do It Scared series, Jen sits down with Kim and Paulette, now the Americana duo Wooten Hill, to talk about the long, slow road out of the world that built them. They share the disastrous wedding venue chapter (Billy and the squirrels!), what changed when they stopped hiding from themselves, why they chose not to blow up their lives, and how they’ve kept love at the center even when it wasn’t returned. Plus, the summer they waited on a grandbaby in Nashville and ended up making the truest record of their lives. Their first full-length album, How Did We Get Here, is out now.

Thought-provoking Quotes:

  • “If I am gay, I’m gonna be gay and have a real relationship. I’m not gonna have some no man’s land.” – Kim Hill
  • “I feel like someone plugged me into an amp. I feel like I sing better.” – Kim Hill
  • “This is the truest art I have ever put out.” – Paulette Wooten
  • “You’re not too late, you’re not broken. You are enough.” – Kim Hill
  • “I find that kind of faith the most faithful kind of faith.” – Jen Hatmaker
  • “Your story has made you softer, not harder.” – Jen Hatmaker

Resources Mentioned in This Episode:

Kim and Penn Holderness on Starting Over, Aging Out Loud, and Getting Ahead of Alzheimer’s

Description:

Twelve years ago, Kim and Penn Holderness made a Christmas card video in their pajamas, it broke the internet, and they both walked away from careers in TV news to make videos full time. With two little kids, two months of savings, and no health insurance. In 2013, when that was not even a job. They have been reinventing ever since, and they are right in the middle of it again.

We recorded this conversation in a very tender week. They had just moved their oldest back to college, and two days earlier, Penn’s mother passed away after nine years in skilled nursing with Alzheimer’s. They showed up anyway, and I am so grateful they did. We talk about the leap of 2013 and the creators who told them every new baby was worth a million followers, what they owe their kids for putting them on the internet before any of us knew better, why every couple should have a podcast even if you never post it, and why they took their family name off their show to start Laugh Lines, all about aging better together.

Then Penn tells me about the Alzheimer’s prevention trial he joined, what he learned about his own genes, the changes he is making now, and how his mom’s brain went to a research study at Duke within an hour of her death so it could help someone else. I was not prepared, and I cried. It is one of the most hopeful things I have ever heard about this disease. This is part of our October series, Courage to Change: Do It Scared. Still to come this month: Sarah Stewart Holland and Beth Silvers of Pantsuit Politics.

Thought-provoking Quotes:

  • There is no such thing as a podcast emergency.
  • Don’t get good at something you don’t really want to do.
  • There’s a moment where you can’t not do that thing.
  • Every couple needs a podcast, even if you don’t post it.
  • When you can hear how you talk to your partner, it is so eye opening.
  • We know what a gift it is to age. I don’t want to be 20. I don’t want to be 40. I’m really thrilled with the age I am.
  • You start saying goodbye to someone the minute they go into skilled nursing.
  • We knew, okay, we’re helping. Her brain’s going to help.
  • We all do what we do. No one’s right or wrong.
  • Everybody behind us will do a better version of it. But it’s kind of fun being on the front edge with y’all.

Resources Mentioned in This Episode:

The For the Love Podcast is presented by Audacy.

 

Encore: Jenna Kutcher on Taking Your Dreams Off the Shelf and Embracing the “What Ifs”

Jenna Kutcher was a few years into a corporate career at Target when her boss slid a five-year plan across the desk. A promotion, more money, more responsibility, all mapped out by somebody else, and every step of it was something she did not want. She did not know yet what she wanted instead, but she knew exactly what she no longer wanted. So she bought a camera off Craigslist for $300.

We’re in the middle of our Courage to Change: Do It Scared series, and I’m bringing back this conversation from January 2023, when it opened our For the Love of What If series. Jenna walks us through how that camera became a photography business, then the Goal Digger podcast, then the New York Times bestseller How Are You, Really?, and why she built the next thing quietly on the side while the paycheck was still coming in. We talk about what happens when more money doesn’t buy the life you’re longing for, why time became her real currency, and the question she asked me that I could not shake: not how does it look, but how does it feel.

Stay for the end, because something happened after this tape. On the last day of 2025, after 968 episodes, Jenna paused Goal Digger while it was still going strong. She meant every word she said here.

Thought-provoking Quotes:

  • Her question is yours now. Not how does it look. How does it feel. (Jen Hatmaker)
  • That is what courage to change actually looks like most of the time. Not a blaze of glory. Not a resignation letter thrown in the air. (Jen Hatmaker)
  • A woman asking an honest question, hearing an answer she did not love, and then doing something about it anyway. (Jen Hatmaker)
  • You are not in prison. You made that rule up, and you are allowed to change it. (Jen Hatmaker)

Barbara Kingsolver on Partita, First Love, and Who Gets to Make Art

Barbara Kingsolver got the offer on her first novel the same day her first daughter was born. She came home from the hospital to a blinking answering machine, and the book came out the week that same baby learned to walk. Almost forty years later, she has a Pulitzer Prize, the National Book Foundation’s medal for a lifetime of work, and a recovery house for women in Lee County, Virginia, built with her Demon Copperhead royalties. She has been one of my literary heroes and true life mentors for decades, and I still cannot believe I got to talk with her.

We talk about what publishing looked like in 1988 versus now, why a slow-building career was a gift to a young mom, and the stubborn hand condition we both live with that ended her public book signings. She walks us through October on her farm in southern Appalachia, where the tomatoes are canned, the peppers are roasted, and she is the one who gets the call when a lamb gets stuck. And she makes the case that rural people are close to half of this country but almost none of what we see on screen, which is why she writes books that work as mirrors for her neighbors and windows for everybody else.

Then we get into Partita, her new novel. Livia was a piano prodigy from east Tennessee who became a small-town piano teacher instead. In her fifties, the first love who derailed her calls and asks to see her, and she has seven days to decide. Barbara built the whole book like a Bach partita, with movements named for old dances and a listening list in the front. She tells us how a small-town girl fell for classical music on her living room floor, why nobody in America wants to talk about class, why revision is where art lives, and about the practice room scene her pianist friend had been waiting her whole life to read.

Thought-provoking Quotes:

  • I became a novelist and a mom the same day. (Barbara Kingsolver)
  • I need my hands to write books. If you let me keep them, I will write you more books. (Barbara Kingsolver)
  • Rural people are close to half of the population of this country, but we are just about zero percent of what you see on television, in the movies, or in the news. (Barbara Kingsolver)
  • I want to write these books that are both mirrors for the people who need to see themselves and windows for the people who don’t know. (Barbara Kingsolver)
  • When you’re in the flow state making something beautiful, that is love too. It’s another kind of love. (Barbara Kingsolver)
  • I love revision. I feel like revision is where art really lives. (Barbara Kingsolver)
  • When I’ve finished a book to my absolute satisfaction and send it out into the world, the work of it is only half done. (Barbara Kingsolver)
  • When I closed Demon Copperhead, I remember thinking, I have just read a masterpiece. (Jen Hatmaker)
  • Some people ask me, how can you be optimistic in these times? And I say, look who I’m dealing with. (Barbara Kingsolver)