I admitted something for the first time on my podcast recently while interviewing (my beloved) Sarah and Beth from Pantsuit Politics:
I didn’t vote in the first two elections I could have: 1992 as a freshman in college when Bill Clinton defeated incumbent George H. W. Bush, and 1996 as a first year teacher when he won reelection against Senate Majority Leader Bob Dole.
I just…didn’t vote. This is so embarrassing and, frankly, confusing to Right Now Me, and I’ve never said it out loud. Even as I sit here, I am mining my memory for what was surely a robust political discussion on my college campus, but I am coming up blank. I vaguely remember watching a debate in the Geiger Center with a bunch of peers, but the only detail I can recall is that Brandon was on a couch nearby and we were trying to catch each other’s eye. I flirted my way through my first election process, internet.
Looking back on the 1996 election, surely the veteran teachers at Jenks East Elementary had something to tell the 22-year-old teacher about educational policies and casting a salient vote for our chosen profession, but my mind is empty. I just can’t remember anything noteworthy except the evangelical bullhorn assuring us that another Clinton presidency was paving the road to perdition. But even then, it must have felt distant enough from me that I phoned it in on November 5th.
Cut to my daughter Sydney who: 1.) registered to vote while we were marching at the 2018 March For Our Lives her senior year.
And 2.) volunteer phone banked that fall for midterms.
I can’t make sweeping statements about generational civic engagement, because certainly millions of my age-mates were active participants in democracy when we were younger, but this crop of 18-29 young adults had the highest percentage of voter turnout in 2020 (55%) since its peak in 1972 (55.4%), the first election in which the voting age was lowered to 18 thanks to the 26th Amendment.
The kids care.
And there is something important here to learn from. We don’t care about what doesn’t matter to us. Apathy is a luxury for anyone unaffected, untargeted, unharmed. Privilege is a reliable enemy of not just voting, but voting for the common good. As I helped Remy get registered to vote this week — I now have five voters! — it occurred to me that we head into the voting booth in one of two mindsets:
Out of Fear
This is easy to manipulate and difficult to reverse. The simplest scapegoat is any vulnerable population that is easy to “other.” When they are coming for your jobs, your safety, your opportunities. When they are trying to radicalize your kids, inflict their identity, pollute the library shelves. When they are violent, drug addicted, exceptionally criminal. When they are ruining American culture, voting illegally, eating your pets. A productive campaign tactic is simply to assure people they are in danger, and certain marginalized groups are to blame. Then it is an easy leap to dehumanizing policies and rhetoric which slowly erodes our collective identity and puts vulnerable populations in actual danger.
Fear is a useful tool in the hands of politicians. Whether our actual wellbeing is in jeopardy or not, fear triggers our fight-or-flight response and creates a cascade effect from making decisions out of scarcity: overestimation of risk, tunnel vision, self focus, and flawed biases. Plus, operating out of fear is corrosive to our own spirit, and we become another of its victims. It is a terrible voting tool but certainly effective for turnout.
Out of Love
There is another story available to us, and that is to walk into the voting booth motivated by love. Our vote is our most powerful tool for the common good. With it, we have the chance to genuinely love our neighbors instead of fear them.
We get to vote for the ongoing protections for our LGBTQIA+ neighbors, because gay people aren’t dangerous but violence incited against them is.
We get to vote for our immigrant neighbors who make our communities so special and mean so much to the fabric of America.
We get to vote for our sisters and daughters and nieces and girlfriends, because reproductive freedom is healthcare, and the next generation is counting on us to show up for them.
We get to vote for our kids who deserve a country that cares that guns now kill more American kids than anything, surpassing accidents and car-related deaths.
We love our kids, therefore we vote for them.
We get to cherish people by the way we vote. We get to say: I am for you, I am with you, I am on your side, I want you to flourish. What an outrageous gift we get to give! We are so lucky to have actual power over the world we are building for our families and neighbors. We also get to hang on to our own wellbeing without being manipulated into constant, irrational terror.
By the way, voting for the common good is also the smartest choice. When our neighbors are thriving, when everyone is cared for, protected, and represented, when equality is prioritized not demonized, whole communities prosper. The GDP goes up, poverty goes down, graduation rates go up, crime goes down, brilliance is unlocked, creativity flourishes, complex problems are solved. Truly, what is good for everyone is good for everyone. Even if you have a lil’ black heart of stone, voting for the common good will improve your actual life, so there’s that.
Voting out of love is maybe not a trending idea, but it should be. The next time an ad or commercial or conversation at your uncle’s house uses the tired tactic of fear, ask yourself what love might have to say instead. Your fear is a useful political tool, but your love can actually help change the world for the better.
I missed my first two presidential elections, but I’ll never miss another. I love my family and neighbors too much to not vote for them.